diff --git a/daggerheart.mjs b/daggerheart.mjs
index 77dad7e8..240d8704 100644
--- a/daggerheart.mjs
+++ b/daggerheart.mjs
@@ -32,6 +32,8 @@ CONFIG.Dice.daggerheart = {
     FateRoll: FateRoll
 };
 
+Object.assign(CONFIG.Dice.termTypes, dice.diceTypes);
+
 CONFIG.Actor.documentClass = documents.DhpActor;
 CONFIG.Actor.dataModels = models.actors.config;
 CONFIG.Actor.collection = collections.DhActorCollection;
diff --git a/module/applications/dialogs/tagTeamDialog.mjs b/module/applications/dialogs/tagTeamDialog.mjs
index 5fdefcbd..2d363471 100644
--- a/module/applications/dialogs/tagTeamDialog.mjs
+++ b/module/applications/dialogs/tagTeamDialog.mjs
@@ -200,6 +200,7 @@ export default class TagTeamDialog extends HandlebarsApplicationMixin(Applicatio
 
             partContext.members[partId] = {
                 ...data,
+                roll: data.roll,
                 isEditable: actor.testUserPermission(game.user, CONST.DOCUMENT_OWNERSHIP_LEVELS.OWNER),
                 key: partId,
                 readyToRoll: Boolean(data.rollChoice),
@@ -448,24 +449,19 @@ export default class TagTeamDialog extends HandlebarsApplicationMixin(Applicatio
         const { member, diceType } = button.dataset;
         const memberData = this.party.system.tagTeam.members[member];
 
-        const dieIndex = diceType === 'hope' ? 0 : diceType === 'fear' ? 2 : 4;
-
-        const { parsedRoll, newRoll } = await game.system.api.dice.DualityRoll.reroll(
-            memberData.rollData,
-            dieIndex,
-            diceType,
-            false
-        );
-        const rollData = parsedRoll.toJSON();
+        const dieIndex = diceType === 'hope' ? 0 : diceType === 'fear' ? 1 : 2;
+        const newRoll = game.system.api.dice.DualityRoll.fromData(memberData.rollData);
+        const dice = newRoll.dice[dieIndex];
+        await dice.reroll(`/r1=${dice.total}`, {
+            liveRoll: {
+                roll: newRoll,
+                isReaction: true
+            }
+        });
+        const rollData = newRoll.toJSON();
         this.updatePartyData(
             {
-                [`system.tagTeam.members.${member}.rollData`]: {
-                    ...rollData,
-                    options: {
-                        ...rollData.options,
-                        roll: newRoll
-                    }
-                }
+                [`system.tagTeam.members.${member}.rollData`]: rollData
             },
             this.getUpdatingParts(button)
         );
@@ -700,7 +696,9 @@ export default class TagTeamDialog extends HandlebarsApplicationMixin(Applicatio
         const error = this.checkInitiatorHopeError(this.party.system.tagTeam.initiator);
         if (error) return error;
 
-        const mainRoll = (await this.getJoinedRoll()).rollData;
+        const joinedRoll = await this.getJoinedRoll();
+        const mainRoll = joinedRoll.rollData;
+        const finalRoll = foundry.utils.deepClone(joinedRoll.roll);
 
         const mainActor = this.party.system.partyMembers.find(x => x.uuid === mainRoll.options.source.actor);
         mainRoll.options.title = game.i18n.localize('DAGGERHEART.APPLICATIONS.TagTeamSelect.chatMessageRollTitle');
@@ -711,7 +709,7 @@ export default class TagTeamDialog extends HandlebarsApplicationMixin(Applicatio
                 title: game.i18n.localize('DAGGERHEART.APPLICATIONS.TagTeamSelect.title'),
                 speaker: cls.getSpeaker({ actor: mainActor }),
                 system: mainRoll.options,
-                rolls: [mainRoll],
+                rolls: [JSON.stringify(joinedRoll.roll)],
                 sound: null,
                 flags: { core: { RollTable: true } }
             };
@@ -723,7 +721,7 @@ export default class TagTeamDialog extends HandlebarsApplicationMixin(Applicatio
         const fearUpdate = { key: 'fear', value: null, total: null, enabled: true };
         for (let memberId in tagTeamData.members) {
             const resourceUpdates = [];
-            const rollGivesHope = mainRoll.options.roll.isCritical || mainRoll.options.roll.result.duality === 1;
+            const rollGivesHope = finalRoll.isCritical || finalRoll.withHope;
             if (memberId === tagTeamData.initiator.memberId) {
                 const value = tagTeamData.initiator.cost
                     ? rollGivesHope
@@ -734,9 +732,8 @@ export default class TagTeamDialog extends HandlebarsApplicationMixin(Applicatio
             } else if (rollGivesHope) {
                 resourceUpdates.push({ key: 'hope', value: 1, total: -1, enabled: true });
             }
-            if (mainRoll.options.roll.isCritical)
-                resourceUpdates.push({ key: 'stress', value: -1, total: 1, enabled: true });
-            if (mainRoll.options.roll.result.duality === -1) {
+            if (finalRoll.isCritical) resourceUpdates.push({ key: 'stress', value: -1, total: 1, enabled: true });
+            if (finalRoll.withFear) {
                 fearUpdate.value = fearUpdate.value === null ? 1 : fearUpdate.value + 1;
                 fearUpdate.total = fearUpdate.total === null ? -1 : fearUpdate.total - 1;
             }
diff --git a/module/applications/ui/chatLog.mjs b/module/applications/ui/chatLog.mjs
index 82300d03..8cbacb09 100644
--- a/module/applications/ui/chatLog.mjs
+++ b/module/applications/ui/chatLog.mjs
@@ -256,7 +256,7 @@ export default class DhpChatLog extends foundry.applications.sidebar.tabs.ChatLo
         action.use(event);
     }
 
-    async rerollEvent(event, message) {
+    async rerollEvent(event, messageData) {
         event.stopPropagation();
         if (!event.shiftKey) {
             const confirmed = await foundry.applications.api.DialogV2.confirm({
@@ -268,6 +268,7 @@ export default class DhpChatLog extends foundry.applications.sidebar.tabs.ChatLo
             if (!confirmed) return;
         }
 
+        const message = game.messages.get(messageData._id);
         const target = event.target.closest('[data-die-index]');
 
         if (target.dataset.type === 'damage') {
@@ -290,27 +291,16 @@ export default class DhpChatLog extends foundry.applications.sidebar.tabs.ChatLo
                 }
             });
         } else {
-            let originalRoll_parsed = message.rolls.map(roll => JSON.parse(roll))[0];
-            const rollClass =
-                game.system.api.dice[
-                    message.type === 'dualityRoll'
-                        ? 'DualityRoll'
-                        : target.dataset.type === 'damage'
-                          ? 'DHRoll'
-                          : 'D20Roll'
-                ];
-
-            if (!game.modules.get('dice-so-nice')?.active) foundry.audio.AudioHelper.play({ src: CONFIG.sounds.dice });
-
-            const { newRoll, parsedRoll } = await rollClass.reroll(
-                originalRoll_parsed,
-                target.dataset.dieIndex,
-                target.dataset.type
-            );
-
-            await game.messages.get(message._id).update({
-                'system.roll': newRoll,
-                'rolls': [parsedRoll]
+            const rerollDice = message.system.roll.dice[target.dataset.dieIndex];
+            await rerollDice.reroll(`/r1=${rerollDice.total}`, {
+                liveRoll: {
+                    roll: message.system.roll,
+                    actor: message.system.actionActor,
+                    isReaction: message.system.roll.options.actionType === 'reaction'
+                }
+            });
+            await message.update({
+                rolls: [message.system.roll.toJSON()]
             });
         }
     }
diff --git a/module/data/chat-message/actorRoll.mjs b/module/data/chat-message/actorRoll.mjs
index 1ea7ff93..e601f86d 100644
--- a/module/data/chat-message/actorRoll.mjs
+++ b/module/data/chat-message/actorRoll.mjs
@@ -32,7 +32,6 @@ export default class DHActorRoll extends foundry.abstract.TypeDataModel {
         return {
             title: new fields.StringField(),
             actionDescription: new fields.HTMLField(),
-            roll: new fields.ObjectField(),
             targets: targetsField(),
             hasRoll: new fields.BooleanField({ initial: false }),
             hasDamage: new fields.BooleanField({ initial: false }),
@@ -55,6 +54,16 @@ export default class DHActorRoll extends foundry.abstract.TypeDataModel {
         };
     }
 
+    get roll() {
+        if (this.parent.type === 'dualityRoll')
+            return this.parent.rolls.find(x => x instanceof game.system.api.dice.DualityRoll);
+
+        if (this.parent.type === 'fateRoll')
+            return this.parent.rolls.find(x => x instanceof game.system.api.dice.FateRoll);
+
+        return null;
+    }
+
     get actionActor() {
         if (!this.source.actor) return null;
         return fromUuidSync(this.source.actor);
diff --git a/module/dice/_module.mjs b/module/dice/_module.mjs
index b9339d87..e1206f82 100644
--- a/module/dice/_module.mjs
+++ b/module/dice/_module.mjs
@@ -4,3 +4,4 @@ export { default as DamageRoll } from './damageRoll.mjs';
 export { default as DHRoll } from './dhRoll.mjs';
 export { default as DualityRoll } from './dualityRoll.mjs';
 export { default as FateRoll } from './fateRoll.mjs';
+export { diceTypes } from './die/_module.mjs';
diff --git a/module/dice/d20Roll.mjs b/module/dice/d20Roll.mjs
index f117ff65..49db18cb 100644
--- a/module/dice/d20Roll.mjs
+++ b/module/dice/d20Roll.mjs
@@ -217,49 +217,11 @@ export default class D20Roll extends DHRoll {
                     results: d.results
                 };
             });
-        data.modifierTotal = this.calculateTotalModifiers(roll);
+        data.modifierTotal = roll.modifierTotal;
         return data;
     }
 
     resetFormula() {
         return (this._formula = this.constructor.getFormula(this.terms));
     }
-
-    static async reroll(rollString, _target, message) {
-        let parsedRoll = game.system.api.dice.D20Roll.fromData(rollString);
-        parsedRoll = await parsedRoll.reroll();
-        const newRoll = game.system.api.dice.D20Roll.postEvaluate(parsedRoll, {
-            targets: message.system.targets,
-            roll: {
-                advantage: message.system.roll.advantage?.type,
-                difficulty: message.system.roll.difficulty ? Number(message.system.roll.difficulty) : null
-            }
-        });
-
-        if (game.modules.get('dice-so-nice')?.active) {
-            await game.dice3d.showForRoll(parsedRoll, game.user, true);
-        }
-
-        const rerolled = {
-            any: true,
-            rerolls: [
-                ...(message.system.roll.dice[0].rerolled?.rerolls?.length > 0
-                    ? [message.system.roll.dice[0].rerolled?.rerolls]
-                    : []),
-                rollString.terms[0].results
-            ]
-        };
-        return {
-            newRoll: {
-                ...newRoll,
-                dice: [
-                    {
-                        ...newRoll.dice[0],
-                        rerolled: rerolled
-                    }
-                ]
-            },
-            parsedRoll
-        };
-    }
 }
diff --git a/module/dice/dhRoll.mjs b/module/dice/dhRoll.mjs
index 3310b9ca..e4a34bd4 100644
--- a/module/dice/dhRoll.mjs
+++ b/module/dice/dhRoll.mjs
@@ -12,6 +12,10 @@ export default class DHRoll extends Roll {
         return game.i18n.localize('DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.Roll.basic');
     }
 
+    get modifierTotal() {
+        return this.constructor.calculateTotalModifiers(this);
+    }
+
     static messageType = 'adversaryRoll';
 
     static CHAT_TEMPLATE = 'systems/daggerheart/templates/ui/chat/roll.hbs';
@@ -138,6 +142,7 @@ export default class DHRoll extends Roll {
         const chatData = await this._prepareChatRenderContext({ flavor, isPrivate, ...options });
         return foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate(template, {
             ...chatData,
+            roll: this,
             parent: chatData.parent,
             targetMode: chatData.targetMode,
             metagamingSettings
@@ -241,16 +246,21 @@ export default class DHRoll extends Roll {
         return (this._formula = this.constructor.getFormula(this.terms));
     }
 
+    /** 
+     * Calculate total modifiers of any rolls, including non-dh rolls.
+     * This exists because damage rolls still may receive base roll classes
+     */
     static calculateTotalModifiers(roll) {
         let modifierTotal = 0;
         for (let i = 0; i < roll.terms.length; i++) {
-            if (
-                roll.terms[i] instanceof foundry.dice.terms.NumericTerm &&
-                !!roll.terms[i - 1] &&
-                roll.terms[i - 1] instanceof foundry.dice.terms.OperatorTerm
-            )
-                modifierTotal += Number(`${roll.terms[i - 1].operator}${roll.terms[i].total}`);
+            if (!roll.terms[i].isDeterministic) continue;
+            const termTotal = roll.terms[i].total;
+            if (typeof termTotal === 'number') {
+                const multiplier = roll.terms[i - 1]?.operator === " - " ? -1 : 1;
+                modifierTotal += multiplier * termTotal;
+            }
         }
+
         return modifierTotal;
     }
 
diff --git a/module/dice/die/_module.mjs b/module/dice/die/_module.mjs
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..ed892f6a
--- /dev/null
+++ b/module/dice/die/_module.mjs
@@ -0,0 +1,9 @@
+import DualityDie from './dualityDie.mjs';
+import AdvantageDie from './advantageDie.mjs';
+import DisadvantageDie from './disadvantageDie.mjs';
+
+export const diceTypes = {
+    DualityDie,
+    AdvantageDie,
+    DisadvantageDie
+};
diff --git a/module/dice/die/advantageDie.mjs b/module/dice/die/advantageDie.mjs
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..9c2f0b03
--- /dev/null
+++ b/module/dice/die/advantageDie.mjs
@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
+export default class AdvantageDie extends foundry.dice.terms.Die {
+    constructor(options) {
+        super(options);
+
+        this.modifiers = [];
+    }
+}
diff --git a/module/dice/die/disadvantageDie.mjs b/module/dice/die/disadvantageDie.mjs
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..f56ebe96
--- /dev/null
+++ b/module/dice/die/disadvantageDie.mjs
@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
+export default class DisadvantageDie extends foundry.dice.terms.Die {
+    constructor(options) {
+        super(options);
+
+        this.modifiers = [];
+    }
+}
diff --git a/module/dice/die/dualityDie.mjs b/module/dice/die/dualityDie.mjs
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..e9deb77f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/module/dice/die/dualityDie.mjs
@@ -0,0 +1,62 @@
+import { ResourceUpdateMap } from '../../data/action/baseAction.mjs';
+
+export default class DualityDie extends foundry.dice.terms.Die {
+    constructor(options) {
+        super(options);
+
+        this.modifiers = [];
+    }
+
+    #getDualityState(roll) {
+        if (!roll) return null;
+        return roll.withHope ? 1 : roll.withFear ? -1 : 0;
+    }
+
+    #updateResources(oldDuality, newDuality, actor) {
+        const { hopeFear } = game.settings.get(CONFIG.DH.id, CONFIG.DH.SETTINGS.gameSettings.Automation);
+        if (game.user.isGM ? !hopeFear.gm : !hopeFear.players) return;
+
+        const updates = [];
+        const hope = (newDuality >= 0 ? 1 : 0) - (oldDuality >= 0 ? 1 : 0);
+        const stress = (newDuality === 0 ? 1 : 0) - (oldDuality === 0 ? 1 : 0);
+        const fear = (newDuality === -1 ? 1 : 0) - (oldDuality === -1 ? 1 : 0);
+
+        if (hope !== 0) updates.push({ key: 'hope', value: hope, total: -1 * hope, enabled: true });
+        if (stress !== 0) updates.push({ key: 'stress', value: -1 * stress, total: stress, enabled: true });
+        if (fear !== 0) updates.push({ key: 'fear', value: fear, total: -1 * fear, enabled: true });
+
+        const resourceUpdates = new ResourceUpdateMap(actor);
+        resourceUpdates.addResources(updates);
+        resourceUpdates.updateResources();
+    }
+
+    async reroll(modifier, options) {
+        const oldDuality = this.#getDualityState(options.liveRoll.roll);
+        await super.reroll(modifier, options);
+
+        if (options?.liveRoll) {
+            /* Can't currently test since DiceSoNice is not v14. Might need to set the appearance earlier if a roll is triggered by super.reroll */
+            if (game.modules.get('dice-so-nice')?.active) {
+                const diceSoNiceRoll = {
+                    _evaluated: true,
+                    dice: [this],
+                    options: { appearance: {} }
+                };
+
+                const preset = await getDiceSoNicePreset(diceSoNice[key], faces);
+                diceSoNiceRoll.dice[0].options.appearance = preset.appearance;
+                diceSoNiceRoll.dice[0].options.modelFile = preset.modelFile;
+
+                await game.dice3d.showForRoll(diceSoNiceRoll, game.user, true);
+            } else {
+                foundry.audio.AudioHelper.play({ src: CONFIG.sounds.dice });
+            }
+
+            await options.liveRoll.roll._evaluate();
+            if (options.liveRoll.isReaction) return;
+
+            const newDuality = this.#getDualityState(options.liveRoll.roll);
+            this.#updateResources(oldDuality, newDuality, options.liveRoll.actor);
+        }
+    }
+}
diff --git a/module/dice/dualityRoll.mjs b/module/dice/dualityRoll.mjs
index 84e0b493..bc381f07 100644
--- a/module/dice/dualityRoll.mjs
+++ b/module/dice/dualityRoll.mjs
@@ -1,8 +1,6 @@
 import D20RollDialog from '../applications/dialogs/d20RollDialog.mjs';
 import D20Roll from './d20Roll.mjs';
 import { parseRallyDice, setDiceSoNiceForDualityRoll } from '../helpers/utils.mjs';
-import { getDiceSoNicePresets } from '../config/generalConfig.mjs';
-import { ResourceUpdateMap } from '../data/action/baseAction.mjs';
 
 export default class DualityRoll extends D20Roll {
     _advantageFaces = 6;
@@ -26,27 +24,31 @@ export default class DualityRoll extends D20Roll {
     }
 
     get dHope() {
-        if (!(this.dice[0] instanceof foundry.dice.terms.Die)) this.createBaseDice();
+        if (!(this.dice[0] instanceof game.system.api.dice.diceTypes.DualityDie)) this.createBaseDice();
         return this.dice[0];
     }
 
     set dHope(faces) {
-        if (!(this.dice[0] instanceof foundry.dice.terms.Die)) this.createBaseDice();
-        this.dice[0].faces = this.getFaces(faces);
+        // TODO this should not be asymmetrical with the getter. updateRollConfiguration() should use dHope.faces
+        this.dHope.faces = this.getFaces(faces);
     }
 
     get dFear() {
-        if (!(this.dice[1] instanceof foundry.dice.terms.Die)) this.createBaseDice();
+        if (!(this.dice[1] instanceof game.system.api.dice.diceTypes.DualityDie)) this.createBaseDice();
         return this.dice[1];
     }
 
     set dFear(faces) {
-        if (!(this.dice[1] instanceof foundry.dice.terms.Die)) this.createBaseDice();
-        this.dice[1].faces = this.getFaces(faces);
+        // TODO this should not be asymmetrical with the getter. updateRollConfiguration() should use dFear.faces
+        this.dFear.faces = this.getFaces(faces);
     }
 
     get dAdvantage() {
-        return this.dice[2];
+        return this.dice[2] instanceof game.system.api.dice.diceTypes.AdvantageDie ? this.dice[2] : null;
+    }
+
+    get dDisadvantage() {
+        return this.dice[2] instanceof game.system.api.dice.diceTypes.DisadvantageDie ? this.dice[2] : null;
     }
 
     get advantageFaces() {
@@ -65,6 +67,11 @@ export default class DualityRoll extends D20Roll {
         this._advantageNumber = Number(value);
     }
 
+    get extraDice() {
+        const { DualityDie, AdvantageDie, DisadvantageDie } = game.system.api.dice.diceTypes;
+        return this.dice.filter(x => ![DualityDie, AdvantageDie, DisadvantageDie].some(die => x instanceof die));
+    }
+
     setRallyChoices() {
         return this.data?.parent?.appliedEffects.reduce((a, c) => {
             const change = c.system.changes.find(ch => ch.key === 'system.bonuses.rally');
@@ -118,22 +125,28 @@ export default class DualityRoll extends D20Roll {
 
     /** @inheritDoc */
     static fromData(data) {
-        data.terms[0].class = foundry.dice.terms.Die.name;
-        data.terms[2].class = foundry.dice.terms.Die.name;
+        data.terms[0].class = 'DualityDie';
+        data.terms[2].class = 'DualityDie';
+        if (data.options.roll.advantage?.type && data.terms[4]?.faces) {
+            data.terms[4].class = data.options.roll.advantage.type === 1 ? 'AdvantageDie' : 'DisadvantageDie';
+        }
         return super.fromData(data);
     }
 
     createBaseDice() {
-        if (this.dice[0] instanceof foundry.dice.terms.Die && this.dice[1] instanceof foundry.dice.terms.Die) {
+        if (
+            this.dice[0] instanceof game.system.api.dice.diceTypes.DualityDie &&
+            this.dice[1] instanceof game.system.api.dice.diceTypes.DualityDie
+        ) {
             this.terms = [this.terms[0], this.terms[1], this.terms[2]];
             return;
         }
 
-        this.terms[0] = new foundry.dice.terms.Die({
+        this.terms[0] = new game.system.api.dice.diceTypes.DualityDie({
             faces: this.data.rules.dualityRoll?.defaultHopeDice ?? 12
         });
         this.terms[1] = new foundry.dice.terms.OperatorTerm({ operator: '+' });
-        this.terms[2] = new foundry.dice.terms.Die({
+        this.terms[2] = new game.system.api.dice.diceTypes.DualityDie({
             faces: this.data.rules.dualityRoll?.defaultFearDice ?? 12
         });
     }
@@ -371,63 +384,4 @@ export default class DualityRoll extends D20Roll {
             if (currentCombatant?.actorId == config.data.id) ui.combat.setCombatantSpotlight(currentCombatant.id);
         }
     }
-
-    static async reroll(rollBase, dieIndex, diceType, updateResources = true) {
-        let parsedRoll = game.system.api.dice.DualityRoll.fromData({ ...rollBase, evaluated: false });
-        const term = parsedRoll.terms[dieIndex];
-        await term.reroll(`/r1=${term.total}`);
-        const result = await parsedRoll.evaluate();
-
-        if (game.modules.get('dice-so-nice')?.active) {
-            const diceSoNiceRoll = {
-                _evaluated: true,
-                dice: [
-                    new foundry.dice.terms.Die({
-                        ...term,
-                        faces: term._faces,
-                        results: term.results.filter(x => !x.rerolled)
-                    })
-                ],
-                options: { appearance: {} }
-            };
-
-            const diceSoNicePresets = await getDiceSoNicePresets(`d${term._faces}`, `d${term._faces}`);
-            if (diceSoNicePresets[diceType]) {
-                diceSoNiceRoll.dice[0].options = diceSoNicePresets[diceType];
-            }
-
-            await game.dice3d.showForRoll(diceSoNiceRoll, game.user, true);
-        } else {
-            foundry.audio.AudioHelper.play({ src: CONFIG.sounds.dice });
-        }
-
-        const newRoll = game.system.api.dice.DualityRoll.postEvaluate(parsedRoll, {
-            targets: parsedRoll.options.targets ?? [],
-            roll: {
-                advantage: parsedRoll.options.roll.advantage?.type,
-                difficulty: parsedRoll.options.roll.difficulty ? Number(parsedRoll.options.roll.difficulty) : null
-            }
-        });
-
-        const extraIndex = newRoll.advantage ? 3 : 2;
-        newRoll.extra = newRoll.extra.slice(extraIndex);
-
-        const actor = parsedRoll.options.source.actor
-            ? await foundry.utils.fromUuid(parsedRoll.options.source.actor)
-            : null;
-        const config = {
-            source: { actor: parsedRoll.options.source.actor ?? '' },
-            targets: parsedRoll.targets,
-            roll: newRoll,
-            rerolledRoll: parsedRoll.options.roll,
-            resourceUpdates: new ResourceUpdateMap(actor)
-        };
-
-        if (updateResources) {
-            await DualityRoll.addDualityResourceUpdates(config);
-            await config.resourceUpdates.updateResources();
-        }
-
-        return { newRoll, parsedRoll };
-    }
 }
diff --git a/module/dice/fateRoll.mjs b/module/dice/fateRoll.mjs
index 418c8465..ec03715a 100644
--- a/module/dice/fateRoll.mjs
+++ b/module/dice/fateRoll.mjs
@@ -21,8 +21,8 @@ export default class FateRoll extends D20Roll {
     }
 
     set dHope(faces) {
-        if (!(this.dice[0] instanceof foundry.dice.terms.Die)) this.createBaseDice();
-        this.dice[0].faces = this.getFaces(faces);
+        // TODO this should not be asymmetrical with the getter. updateRollConfiguration() should use dHope.faces
+        this.dHope.faces = this.getFaces(faces);
     }
 
     get dFear() {
@@ -31,8 +31,8 @@ export default class FateRoll extends D20Roll {
     }
 
     set dFear(faces) {
-        if (!(this.dice[0] instanceof foundry.dice.terms.Die)) this.createBaseDice();
-        this.dice[0].faces = this.getFaces(faces);
+        // TODO this should not be asymmetrical with the getter. updateRollConfiguration() should use dFear.faces
+        this.dFear.faces = this.getFaces(faces);
     }
 
     get isCritical() {
@@ -43,6 +43,22 @@ export default class FateRoll extends D20Roll {
         return this.data.fateType;
     }
 
+    get withHope() {
+        if (!this._evaluatedl) return;
+        return this.dHope.total >= this.dFear.total;
+    }
+
+    get withFear() {
+        if (!this._evaluated) return;
+        return this.dHope.total < this.dFear.total;
+    }
+
+    get totalLabel() {
+        const label = this.withHope ? 'DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.hope' : 'DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.fear';
+
+        return game.i18n.localize(label);
+    }
+
     static getHooks(hooks) {
         return [...(hooks ?? []), 'Fate'];
     }
diff --git a/module/documents/chatMessage.mjs b/module/documents/chatMessage.mjs
index 8b094678..307677bb 100644
--- a/module/documents/chatMessage.mjs
+++ b/module/documents/chatMessage.mjs
@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
-import { emitAsGM, GMUpdateEvent, RefreshType, socketEvent } from '../systemRegistration/socket.mjs';
+import { emitAsGM, GMUpdateEvent } from '../systemRegistration/socket.mjs';
 
 export default class DhpChatMessage extends foundry.documents.ChatMessage {
     targetHook = null;
@@ -78,25 +78,14 @@ export default class DhpChatMessage extends foundry.documents.ChatMessage {
         if (this.isContentVisible) {
             if (this.type === 'dualityRoll') {
                 html.classList.add('duality');
-                switch (this.system.roll?.result?.duality) {
-                    case 1:
-                        html.classList.add('hope');
-                        break;
-                    case -1:
-                        html.classList.add('fear');
-                        break;
-                    default:
-                        html.classList.add('critical');
-                        break;
-                }
+                if (this.system.roll.withHope) html.classList.add('hope');
+                else if (this.system.roll.withFear) html.classList.add('fear');
+                else html.classList.add('critical');
             }
             if (this.type === 'fateRoll') {
                 html.classList.add('fate');
-                if (this.system.roll?.fate.fateDie == 'Hope') {
-                    html.classList.add('hope');
-                }
-                if (this.system.roll?.fate.fateDie == 'Fear') {
-                    html.classList.add('fear');
+                if (this.system.roll?.fateDie) {
+                    html.classList.add(this.system.roll.fateDie.toLowerCase());
                 }
             }
 
diff --git a/styles/less/ui/chat/chat.less b/styles/less/ui/chat/chat.less
index e9ef9147..db6dceb9 100644
--- a/styles/less/ui/chat/chat.less
+++ b/styles/less/ui/chat/chat.less
@@ -384,6 +384,15 @@
                     justify-content: center;
                     width: 15px;
                 }
+                &.has-minus:before {
+                    content: '-';
+                    font-size: var(--font-size-20);
+                    grid-area: c;
+                    display: flex;
+                    align-items: center;
+                    justify-content: center;
+                    width: 15px;
+                }
             }
         }
 
diff --git a/templates/dialogs/dice-roll/rollSelection.hbs b/templates/dialogs/dice-roll/rollSelection.hbs
index 4451160b..64a3cdcb 100644
--- a/templates/dialogs/dice-roll/rollSelection.hbs
+++ b/templates/dialogs/dice-roll/rollSelection.hbs
@@ -53,14 +53,14 @@
                         {{#if @root.advantage}}
                             {{#if (eq @root.advantage 1)}}
                                 <div class="dice-option">
-                                    <img class="dice-icon" src="{{concat 'systems/daggerheart/assets/icons/dice/adv/' @root.roll.dAdvantage.denomination '.svg'}}" alt="">
+                                    <img class="dice-icon" src="{{concat 'systems/daggerheart/assets/icons/dice/adv/d' @root.roll.advantageFaces '.svg'}}" alt="">
                                     <div class="dice-select">
                                         <span class="label">{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.Advantage.full"}}</span>
                                     </div>
                                 </div>
                             {{else if (eq @root.advantage -1)}}
                                 <div class="dice-option">
-                                    <img class="dice-icon" src="{{concat 'systems/daggerheart/assets/icons/dice/disadv/' @root.roll.dAdvantage.denomination '.svg'}}" alt="">
+                                    <img class="dice-icon" src="{{concat 'systems/daggerheart/assets/icons/dice/disadv/d' @root.roll.advantageFaces '.svg'}}" alt="">
                                     <div class="dice-select">
                                         <span class="label">{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.Disadvantage.full"}}</span>
                                     </div>
@@ -158,7 +158,7 @@
                                     {{/times}}
                                 </select>
                                 <select name="roll.dice.advantageFaces"{{#unless advantage}} disabled{{/unless}}>
-                                    {{selectOptions diceOptions selected=@root.roll.dAdvantage.denomination}}
+                                    {{selectOptions diceOptions selected=(concat 'd' @root.roll.advantageFaces)}}
                                 </select>
                             </div>
                             {{#if abilities}}
diff --git a/templates/dialogs/tagTeamDialog/parts/tagTeamDamageParts.hbs b/templates/dialogs/tagTeamDialog/parts/tagTeamDamageParts.hbs
index 058777a5..49fc8f4f 100644
--- a/templates/dialogs/tagTeamDialog/parts/tagTeamDamageParts.hbs
+++ b/templates/dialogs/tagTeamDialog/parts/tagTeamDamageParts.hbs
@@ -7,7 +7,7 @@
         {{#each damage.parts as |part|}}
             <div class="roll-dice-container">
                 {{#each part.dice as |dice index|}}
-                    <a class="roll-dice" data-action="rerollDamageDice" data-member-key="{{@../../../key}}" data-damage-key="{{@../../key}}" data-part="{{@../index}}" data-dice="{{index}}">
+                    <a class="roll-dice" data-action="rerollDamageDice" data-member-key="{{../../../key}}" data-damage-key="{{@../../key}}" data-part="{{@../index}}" data-dice="{{index}}">
                         <span class="dice-label">{{dice.total}}</span>
                         <img src="{{concat "systems/daggerheart/assets/icons/dice/hope/" dice.dice ".svg"}}" />
                     </a>
diff --git a/templates/dialogs/tagTeamDialog/tagTeamMember.hbs b/templates/dialogs/tagTeamDialog/tagTeamMember.hbs
index 5c100d02..7510422f 100644
--- a/templates/dialogs/tagTeamDialog/tagTeamMember.hbs
+++ b/templates/dialogs/tagTeamDialog/tagTeamMember.hbs
@@ -62,32 +62,30 @@
                             </div>
                         </span>
 
-                        {{#if rollData}}
-                            {{#with rollData.options.roll}}
-                                <div class="roll-data {{#if this.isCritical}}critical{{else}}{{#if (eq this.result.duality 1)}}hope{{else}}fear{{/if}}{{/if}}">
-                                    <div class="duality-label">{{this.total}} {{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.withThing" thing=this.result.label}}</div>
-                                    <div class="roll-dice-container">
-                                        <a class="roll-dice" data-action="rerollDice" data-member="{{@root.partId}}" data-dice-type="hope">
-                                            <span class="dice-label">{{this.hope.value}}</span>
-                                            <img src="{{concat "systems/daggerheart/assets/icons/dice/hope/" this.hope.dice ".svg"}}" />
-                                        </a>
-                                        <span class="roll-operator">+</span>
-                                        <a class="roll-dice" data-action="rerollDice" data-member="{{@root.partId}}" data-dice-type="fear">
-                                            <span class="dice-label">{{this.fear.value}}</span>
-                                            <img src="{{concat "systems/daggerheart/assets/icons/dice/fear/" this.fear.dice ".svg"}}" />
-                                        </a>
-                                        {{#if this.advantage.type}}
-                                            <span class="roll-operator">{{#if (eq this.advantage.type 1)}}+{{else}}-{{/if}}</span>
-                                            <span class="roll-dice">
-                                                <span class="dice-label">{{this.advantage.value}}</span>
-                                                <img src="{{concat "systems/daggerheart/assets/icons/dice/" (ifThen (eq this.advantage.type 1) "adv/" "disadv/") this.advantage.dice ".svg"}}" />
-                                            </span>
-                                        {{/if}}
-                                        <span class="roll-operator">{{#if (gte this.modifierTotal 0)}}+{{else}}-{{/if}}</span>
-                                        <span class="roll-value">{{positive this.modifierTotal}}</span>
-                                    </div>
+                        {{#if roll}}
+                            <div class="roll-data {{#if roll.withHope}}hope{{else if roll.withFear}}fear{{else}}critical{{/if}}">
+                                <div class="duality-label">{{roll.total}} {{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.withThing" thing=roll.totalLabel}}</div>
+                                <div class="roll-dice-container">
+                                    <a class="roll-dice" data-action="rerollDice" data-member="{{@root.partId}}" data-dice-type="hope">
+                                        <span class="dice-label">{{roll.dHope.total}}</span>
+                                        <img src="{{concat "systems/daggerheart/assets/icons/dice/hope/" roll.dHope.denomination ".svg"}}" />
+                                    </a>
+                                    <span class="roll-operator">+</span>
+                                    <a class="roll-dice" data-action="rerollDice" data-member="{{@root.partId}}" data-dice-type="fear">
+                                        <span class="dice-label">{{roll.dFear.total}}</span>
+                                        <img src="{{concat "systems/daggerheart/assets/icons/dice/fear/" roll.dFear.denomination ".svg"}}" />
+                                    </a>
+                                    {{#if roll.advantage.type}}
+                                        <span class="roll-operator">{{#if (eq roll.advantage.type 1)}}+{{else}}-{{/if}}</span>
+                                        <span class="roll-dice">
+                                            <span class="dice-label">{{roll.advantage.value}}</span>
+                                            <img src="{{concat "systems/daggerheart/assets/icons/dice/" (ifThen (eq roll.advantage.type 1) "adv/" "disadv/") roll.advantage.dice ".svg"}}" />
+                                        </span>
+                                    {{/if}}
+                                    <span class="roll-operator">{{#if (gte roll.modifierTotal 0)}}+{{else}}-{{/if}}</span>
+                                    <span class="roll-value">{{positive roll.modifierTotal}}</span>
                                 </div>
-                            {{/with}}
+                            </div>
                         {{else}}
                             <span class="hint">{{localize "DAGGERHEART.APPLICATIONS.TagTeamSelect.makeYourRoll"}}</span>
                         {{/if}}
diff --git a/templates/dialogs/tagTeamDialog/tagTeamRoll.hbs b/templates/dialogs/tagTeamDialog/tagTeamRoll.hbs
index 478255ce..79b5138e 100644
--- a/templates/dialogs/tagTeamDialog/tagTeamRoll.hbs
+++ b/templates/dialogs/tagTeamDialog/tagTeamRoll.hbs
@@ -6,16 +6,16 @@
                 {{#if hintText}}
                     <div class="hint">{{localize hintText}}</div>
                 {{else}}
-                    {{#if joinedRoll.rollData}}
+                    {{#if joinedRoll.roll}}
                         <div class="result-container">
                             <span class="result-section-label">{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.dualityRoll"}}</span>
                             <div class="result-info">
-                                <div class="damage-info">{{joinedRoll.rollData.options.roll.total}}</div>
-                                <div>{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.withThing" thing=joinedRoll.rollData.options.roll.result.label}}</div>
+                                <div class="damage-info">{{joinedRoll.roll.total}}</div>
+                                <div>{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.withThing" thing=joinedRoll.roll.totalLabel}}</div>
                             </div>
                         </div>
                     {{/if}}
-                    {{#if hasDamage}}
+                    {{#if joinedRoll.rollData.options.hasDamage}}
                         <div class="result-container">
                             <span class="result-section-label">{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.damage"}}</span>
                             {{#each joinedRoll.rollData.options.damage as |damage key|}}
diff --git a/templates/ui/chat/parts/roll-part.hbs b/templates/ui/chat/parts/roll-part.hbs
index ea962f9e..850f0e92 100644
--- a/templates/ui/chat/parts/roll-part.hbs
+++ b/templates/ui/chat/parts/roll-part.hbs
@@ -7,7 +7,7 @@
                     <span>{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.criticalShort"}}</span>
                 {{else}}
                     {{#if (and roll.result (not (eq roll.type "reaction")))}}
-                        <span>{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.withThing" thing=roll.result.label}}</span>
+                        <span>{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.withThing" thing=roll.totalLabel}}</span>
                     {{/if}}
                 {{/if}}
             </span>
@@ -29,48 +29,48 @@
             <div class="dice-tooltip">
                 <div class="wrapper">
                     <div class="roll-dice">
-                        {{#if roll.fate}}
-                            {{#if (eq roll.fate.fateDie "Hope")}}
+                        {{#if roll.fateDie}}
+                            {{#if (eq roll.fateDie "Hope")}}
                                 <div class="roll-die">
                                     <label>{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.hope"}}</label>
-                                    <div class="dice {{roll.fate.dice}} color-hope" data-die-index="0" data-type="hope">
-                                         {{roll.fate.value}}
+                                    <div class="dice {{roll.dHope.denomination}} color-hope" data-die-index="0" data-type="hope">
+                                         {{roll.dHope.total}}
                                     </div>
                                 </div>
                             {{/if}}
-                            {{#if (eq roll.fate.fateDie "Fear")}}
+                            {{#if (eq roll.fateDie "Fear")}}
                                 <div class="roll-die">
                                     <label>{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.fear"}}</label>
-                                    <div class="dice {{roll.fate.dice}} color-fear" data-die-index="0" data-type="fear">
-                                         {{roll.fate.value}}
+                                    <div class="dice {{roll.dFear.denomination}} color-fear" data-die-index="0" data-type="fear">
+                                         {{roll.dFear.total}}
                                     </div>
                                 </div>
                             {{/if}}
                         {{else}}
-                            {{#if roll.hope}}
+                            {{#if roll.dHope}}
                                 <div class="roll-die">
                                     <label>{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.hope"}}</label>
-                                    <div class="dice {{roll.hope.dice}} color-hope reroll-button" data-die-index="0" data-type="hope" data-tooltip="{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.rerollThing" thing=(localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.hope")}}">
-                                        {{#if roll.hope.rerolled.any}}<i class="fa-solid fa-dice dice-rerolled" data-tooltip="{{localize "DAGGERHEART.UI.Tooltip.diceIsRerolled" times=roll.hope.rerolled.rerolls.length}}"></i>{{/if}}
-                                        {{roll.hope.value}}
+                                    <div class="dice {{roll.dHope.denomination}} color-hope reroll-button" data-die-index="0" data-type="hope" data-tooltip="{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.rerollThing" thing=(localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.hope")}}">
+                                        {{#if roll.dHopehope.rerolled.any}}<i class="fa-solid fa-dice dice-rerolled" data-tooltip="{{localize "DAGGERHEART.UI.Tooltip.diceIsRerolled" times=roll.dHope.rerolled.rerolls.length}}"></i>{{/if}}
+                                        {{roll.dHope.total}}
                                     </div>
                                 </div>
                                 <div class="roll-die has-plus">
                                     <label>{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.fear"}}</label>
-                                    <div class="dice {{roll.fear.dice}} color-fear reroll-button" data-die-index="2" data-type="fear" style="--svg-folder: 'fear';" data-tooltip="{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.rerollThing" thing=(localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.fear")}}">
-                                        {{#if roll.fear.rerolled.any}}<i class="fa-solid fa-dice dice-rerolled" data-tooltip="{{localize "DAGGERHEART.UI.Tooltip.diceIsRerolled" times=roll.fear.rerolled.rerolls.length}}"></i>{{/if}}
-                                        {{roll.fear.value}}
+                                    <div class="dice {{roll.dFear.denomination}} color-fear reroll-button" data-die-index="1" data-type="fear" style="--svg-folder: 'fear';" data-tooltip="{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.rerollThing" thing=(localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.fear")}}">
+                                        {{#if roll.dFear.rerolled.any}}<i class="fa-solid fa-dice dice-rerolled" data-tooltip="{{localize "DAGGERHEART.UI.Tooltip.diceIsRerolled" times=roll.dFear.rerolled.rerolls.length}}"></i>{{/if}}
+                                        {{roll.dFear.total}}
                                     </div>
                                 </div>
-                                {{#if roll.advantage.type}}
+                                {{#if roll.dAdvantage}}
                                     <div class="roll-die has-plus">
-                                        {{#if (eq roll.advantage.type 1)}}
-                                            <label>{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.Advantage.short"}}</label>
-                                            <div class="dice {{roll.advantage.dice}} color-adv">{{roll.advantage.value}}</div>
-                                        {{else}}
-                                            <label>{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.Disadvantage.short"}}</label>
-                                            <div class="dice {{roll.advantage.dice}} color-dis">{{roll.advantage.value}}</div>
-                                        {{/if}}
+                                        <label>{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.Advantage.short"}}</label>
+                                        <div class="dice {{roll.dAdvantage.denomination}} color-adv">{{roll.dAdvantage.total}}</div>
+                                    </div>
+                                {{else if roll.dDisadvantage}}
+                                    <div class="roll-die has-minus">
+                                        <label>{{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.Disadvantage.short"}}</label>
+                                        <div class="dice {{roll.dDisadvantage.denomination}} color-dis">{{roll.dDisadvantage.total}}</div>
                                     </div>
                                 {{/if}}
                                 {{#if roll.rally.dice}}
@@ -79,15 +79,11 @@
                                         <div class="dice {{roll.rally.dice}}">{{roll.rally.value}}</div>
                                     </div>
                                 {{/if}}
-                                {{#each roll.extra}}
-                                    {{#each results}}
-                                        {{#unless discarded}}
-                                            <div class="roll-die has-plus">
-                                                <label></label>
-                                                <div class="dice {{../dice}}">{{result}}</div>
-                                            </div>
-                                        {{/unless}}
-                                    {{/each}}
+                                {{#each roll.extraDice}}
+                                    <div class="roll-die has-plus">
+                                        <label></label>
+                                        <div class="dice {{this.denomination}}">{{this.total}}</div>
+                                    </div>
                                 {{/each}}
                             {{else}}
                                 {{#each roll.dice}}