diff --git a/module/applications/sheets-configs/action-base-config.mjs b/module/applications/sheets-configs/action-base-config.mjs
index a20cc251..51243f39 100644
--- a/module/applications/sheets-configs/action-base-config.mjs
+++ b/module/applications/sheets-configs/action-base-config.mjs
@@ -1,3 +1,4 @@
+import { AltDamageOutcome } from '../../data/fields/action/damageField.mjs';
 import { getUnusedDamageTypes } from '../../helpers/utils.mjs';
 import DaggerheartSheet from '../sheets/daggerheart-sheet.mjs';
 
@@ -62,7 +63,7 @@ export default class DHActionBaseConfig extends DaggerheartSheet(ApplicationV2)
             id: 'configuration',
             template: 'systems/daggerheart/templates/sheets-settings/action-settings/configuration.hbs'
         },
-        configuration: {
+        range: {
             id: 'range',
             template: 'systems/daggerheart/templates/sheets-settings/action-settings/range.hbs'
         },
@@ -120,19 +121,19 @@ export default class DHActionBaseConfig extends DaggerheartSheet(ApplicationV2)
     };
 
     static OUTCOME_TABS = {
-        successWithHope: {
+        successHope: {
             active: true,
             cssClass: '',
             group: 'outcomes',
-            id: 'successWithHope',
+            id: 'successHope',
             icon: null,
             label: 'Success With Hope'
         },
-        successWithFear: {
+        successFear: {
             active: false,
             cssClass: '',
             group: 'outcomes',
-            id: 'successWithFear',
+            id: 'successFear',
             icon: null,
             label: 'Success With Fear'
         },
@@ -188,7 +189,6 @@ export default class DHActionBaseConfig extends DaggerheartSheet(ApplicationV2)
         context.tabs = this._getTabs(this.constructor.TABS);
         
         context.outcomeTabs = this._getTabs(this.constructor.OUTCOME_TABS);
-        context.outcomeData = context.outcomeTabs.successWithHope.active ? context.source.damage : context.source.damage.altOutcomes.successWithFear;
 
         context.config = CONFIG.DH;
         if (this.action.damage) {
@@ -334,9 +334,10 @@ export default class DHActionBaseConfig extends DaggerheartSheet(ApplicationV2)
         this.constructor.updateForm.bind(this)(null, null, { object: foundry.utils.flattenObject(data) });
     }
 
-    static addDamage(_event) {
+    static addDamage(_event, button) {
         if (!this.action.damage.parts) return;
 
+        const outcome = button.dataset.outcome;
         const choices = getUnusedDamageTypes(this.action._source.damage.parts);
         const content = new foundry.data.fields.StringField({
             label: game.i18n.localize('Damage Type'),
@@ -360,7 +361,16 @@ export default class DHActionBaseConfig extends DaggerheartSheet(ApplicationV2)
             if (type === CONFIG.DH.GENERAL.healingTypes.hitPoints.id)
                 part.type = this.action.schema.fields.damage.fields.parts.element.fields.type.element.initial;
 
-            data.damage.parts[type] = part;
+            if (outcome === 'successHope')
+                data.damage.parts[type] = part;
+            else {
+                if (!data.damage.altOutcomes[outcome]) {
+                    data.damage.altOutcomes[outcome] = new AltDamageOutcome();
+                }
+
+                data.damage.altOutcomes[outcome].parts[type] = part;
+            }
+
             this.constructor.updateForm.bind(this)(null, null, { object: foundry.utils.flattenObject(data) });
         };
 
diff --git a/module/data/fields/action/damageField.mjs b/module/data/fields/action/damageField.mjs
index ba8277ef..6c0d2a88 100644
--- a/module/data/fields/action/damageField.mjs
+++ b/module/data/fields/action/damageField.mjs
@@ -343,16 +343,18 @@ export class DHDamageData extends DHResourceData {
     }
 }
 
-class AltDamageOutcome extends foundry.abstract.DataModel {
+export class AltDamageOutcome extends foundry.abstract.DataModel {
     static defineSchema() {
         return {
-            copyStandard: new fields.BooleanField({ required: true, initial: true }),
+            useStandardHitPointDamage: new fields.BooleanField({ required: true, initial: true }),
             ...getDamageBaseFields(),
-            /* Stuff */
         }
     }
 
     get data() {
-        return this.copyStandard ? this.parent : {}; // If not copying, return data from the this alternate outcome
+        return {
+            ...this.parent,
+            ...this,
+        }
     }
 }
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/templates/actionTypes/damage.hbs b/templates/actionTypes/damage.hbs
index 03300840..f1952c78 100644
--- a/templates/actionTypes/damage.hbs
+++ b/templates/actionTypes/damage.hbs
@@ -6,7 +6,7 @@
         {{else}}
             {{localize "DAGGERHEART.GENERAL.damage"}}
         {{/if}}
-        {{#unless (eq path 'system.attack.')}}<a data-action="addDamage" {{#if @root.allDamageTypesUsed}}disabled{{/if}}><i class="fa-solid fa-plus icon-button"></i></a>{{/unless}}
+        {{#unless (eq path 'system.attack.')}}<a data-action="addDamage" data-outcome="{{outcome}}" {{#if @root.allDamageTypesUsed}}disabled{{/if}}><i class="fa-solid fa-plus icon-button"></i></a>{{/unless}}
     </legend>
     <div class="nest-inputs">
         {{#if @root.hasBaseDamage}}
@@ -19,7 +19,7 @@
             {{formField baseFields.groupAttack value=source.groupAttack name=(concat path "damage.groupAttack") localize=true classes="select"}}
         {{/if}}
     </div>
-
+    
     {{!-- Handlebars uses Symbol.Iterator to produce index|key. This isn't compatible with our parts object, so we instead use applyTo, which is the same value --}}
     {{#each source.parts as |dmg key|}}
         <div class="nest-inputs">
diff --git a/templates/sheets-settings/action-settings/effect.hbs b/templates/sheets-settings/action-settings/effect.hbs
index aa22a28e..ea30eddf 100644
--- a/templates/sheets-settings/action-settings/effect.hbs
+++ b/templates/sheets-settings/action-settings/effect.hbs
@@ -12,8 +12,23 @@
             </div>
         {{/each}}
     </nav>
+    
+    {{#each outcomeTabs as |tab|}}
+        <section 
+            class="tab {{lookup (lookup ../outcomeTabs tab.id) 'cssClass'}}"
+            data-group="outcomes"
+            data-tab="{{tab.id}}"
+        >
+            {{#if (eq tab.id 'successHope')}}
+                {{#if ../fields.damage}}{{> 'systems/daggerheart/templates/actionTypes/damage.hbs' fields=../fields.damage.fields.parts.element.fields source=../source.damage baseFields=../fields.damage.fields outcome=tab.id }}{{/if}}
+            {{else}}
+                {{#with (lookup ../fields.damage.fields.altOutcomes.fields tab.id) as |field|}}
+                    {{> 'systems/daggerheart/templates/actionTypes/damage.hbs' fields=field.fields.parts.element.fields source=(lookup ../../source.damage.altOutcomes ../id) baseFields=field.fields outcome=../id }}
+                {{/with }}
+            {{/if}}
+        </section>
+    {{/each}}
 
-    {{#if fields.damage}}{{> 'systems/daggerheart/templates/actionTypes/damage.hbs' fields=fields.damage.fields.parts.element.fields source=outcomeData baseFields=fields.damage.fields }}{{/if}}
     {{#if fields.macro}}{{> 'systems/daggerheart/templates/actionTypes/macro.hbs' fields=fields.macro source=source.macro}}{{/if}}
     {{#if fields.effects}}{{> 'systems/daggerheart/templates/actionTypes/effect.hbs' fields=fields.effects.element.fields source=source.effects}}{{/if}}
     {{#if fields.beastform}}{{> 'systems/daggerheart/templates/actionTypes/beastform.hbs' fields=fields.beastform.fields source=source.beastform}}{{/if}}